Get Started

Pie Insurance vs WithCoverage

How Pie Insurance’s workers’ compensation program differs from WithCoverage’s broader restaurant risk-management and brokerage service.

Introduction

Pie Insurance sells and administers workers’ compensation written by affiliated carriers, with payroll-based billing and online policyholder tools. WithCoverage is a commercial brokerage and risk-management service whose restaurant practice addresses general liability, liquor liability and workers’ compensation. A restaurant operator adding locations should decide whether it is choosing an employee-injury policy, outsourcing broader insurance work, or making both decisions together. 5 18 15 27 32

Where Each Provider Shines

Where Pie Insurance Shines

  • Small businesses can start a workers’ compensation quote directly online or through an insurance agent. 2,1,3
  • Workers’ compensation payment options include pay-as-you-go using reported payroll, with no initial deposit. 17,18

Where WithCoverage Shines

  • An initial policy audit can start while you retain your existing broker, comparing coverage, limits and premiums with market benchmarks. 29
  • WithCoverage describes a named risk manager handling renewals, certificates and account questions, backed by a broader specialist team. 32,26

Coverage Comparison

Coverage TypePie InsuranceWithCoverage
Builders riskNot listedListed 31
Business owner’s policyListed 7Not listed
Cargo and transitNot listedListed 30
Commercial propertyNot listedListed 31
Cyber liabilityListed 8Listed 29
Directors and officersNot listedListed 29
General liabilityListed 10Listed 31,32
Liquor liabilityNot listedListed 32
Product liabilityNot listedListed 30
Product recallNot listedListed 30
Professional liability / E&OListed 9Listed 29
Umbrella and excess liabilityNot listedListed 31
Workers’ compensationListed 3Listed 31,32

Listed products and programs, including policies arranged through insurers or partners. Optional endorsements are discussed in the analysis below. “Not listed” means no separate offering appears in the reviewed catalogue; confirm availability and policy terms with the provider.

Key Differences Between Pie Insurance and WithCoverage

Workplace Policies and Operating Programs

Pie’s workers’ compensation program provides a concrete product to evaluate for the restaurant’s employees. It also offers selected outside-carrier products, including general liability and a business owner’s policy. WithCoverage reviews and arranges a wider restaurant program, explicitly including liquor liability. The buyer should supply each the same staffing, premises and alcohol-service description, then ask which requirements are addressed by each proposed policy. 3 10 7 32

If the new location adds bar service, a workers’ compensation proposal does not answer the liquor question. Conversely, WithCoverage’s restaurant focus does not establish insurer acceptance for every venue or activity. Ask for the actual liquor terms and insurer, while retaining a separate comparison of employee coverage and payroll costs. The broader advisory service and the workers’ compensation product need not be treated as substitutes. 32 28 3

Pie supports appointed agencies as well as direct purchase. An operator can ask its chosen broker about access to the desired workers’ compensation program, but no reviewed source establishes a WithCoverage–Pie appointment. Confirm access and responsibilities before expecting a single relationship to coordinate both. 2 36

Payroll Controls and Seasonal Staffing

Pie’s pay-as-you-go arrangement uses actual reported payroll for monthly payments and advertises no initial deposit. That is relevant if the restaurant hires seasonally or ramps up a new location. Ask how payroll connects to billing, how employees working across locations are recorded and who corrects reporting errors. 18 19

Pie’s annual audit still reconciles the premium using actual payroll information. Its audit guidance also asks for duties and subcontractor insurance documents. WithCoverage’s named risk-manager description addresses ongoing restaurant service, but does not by itself establish who performs payroll reporting or manages a particular carrier’s audit. Put those duties in the proposed service scope, including what remains with the payroll team. 19 32

Reviews, Broker Changes and Policy Replacement

WithCoverage says its initial audit does not require leaving the incumbent broker. Its portfolio materials separately describe taking over existing policies through a broker-of-record appointment. If the restaurant already has Pie coverage, ask whether the actual policy can be serviced by the intended broker; neither the general transfer description nor Pie’s agency distribution establishes that particular transfer right. 29 35 2

A transfer also does not insure the new location automatically. Ask for insurer confirmation of changed locations and duties, and a separate proposal if replacement is required. Pie’s public footprint counts conflict, making location-specific confirmation more useful than relying on a state total. WithCoverage’s producer-license list likewise is not a product availability schedule. 11 13 4 38 28

Premiums, Fees and Included Work

Pie publishes a 3% credit-card convenience fee for new, single-state workers’ compensation policies, except in Florida, Nebraska, Maryland and Rhode Island. Its page does not describe this fee for multi-state or renewal policies. 17

Pie also publishes payment schedules and state-dependent waiver charges. WithCoverage typically agrees a flat fee but allows commission arrangements and other disclosed charges. A Pie policy premium and a WithCoverage advisory fee purchase different things: request a full program cost that includes the insurer premium, advisory compensation and applicable payment or endorsement charges. 17 16 30 28

The solution page advertises average savings of 20–40% for clients spending over $1 million annually on insurance and risk-management services. It does not provide the sample size, measurement period or calculation needed to establish a comparable result for your business. 33

For a smaller restaurant group, that published scope does not establish expected savings. Even within that scope, the advertised result is not a quote. If the proposed program changes deductibles or shifts more risk to the operator, identify that separately from any reduced premium and include the service fee in the comparison. 33 36

Injury Procedures by Location

Pie asks for prompt workplace-injury reporting and describes follow-up by a claims professional. WithCoverage describes claims-team support and recommendations intended to reduce future exposure. These can be complementary tasks: the policy administrator handles the claim process, while an advisor can help the business coordinate and learn from incidents. Confirm the actual assignment rather than assuming the broker receives every required notice. 20 33

Pie’s public handler allocation varies by state and does not fully reconcile with its footprint count. WithCoverage’s attorney involvement also should not be mistaken for legal representation; its portfolio page says it does not provide legal services. Record the state-specific administrator, insurer reporting instructions and the broker’s escalation role. Neither description establishes a better settlement outcome. 21 35 28

What to Confirm in Quotes

  • A location-and-duties schedule: confirm payroll classifications, new premises, alcohol service and the separate policies proposed for each exposure. 3 32
  • A payroll and audit assignment: specify reporting, corrections, record retention and help reviewing the final adjustment. 18 19 32
  • A transfer or replacement plan: confirm actual program access, insurer acceptance and dates rather than assuming an appointment changes coverage. 2 35
  • A complete price and service schedule: separate premiums, fees, commissions, payment charges and retained risk, and name the injury contact at each location. 17 21 30 33

Service Comparison

Pie Insurance vs WithCoverage: documented services and availability

CriteriaPie InsuranceWithCoverage
Customer focus

Pie markets its workers’ compensation program to small businesses, both directly and through local, regional and national insurance agencies. 2,3

Its main industry pages address technology, consumer brands, construction, real estate and restaurants. The company positions its team as an alternative to building an in-house risk-management function. 26,27

Application process

A small business can start a workers’ compensation quote on Pie’s website or work through an insurance agent; appointed agencies use a separate partner portal. 2,1,3

The live direct quote starts with the business ZIP code. Pie’s workers’ compensation page says applicants also need their name, business name, annual payroll and class-code information. 6,3

Pie advertises an online workers’ compensation quote in about three minutes, while expressly stating that individual quote times vary. This is a company claim and does not establish how long underwriting or binding will take for a particular risk. 3,1

WithCoverage offers an initial policy audit without requiring you to leave your broker. It says the review compares existing coverage, limits and premiums with market benchmarks. Its technology FAQ puts the assessment at usually one business day after receiving policy documents, with longer timing for multiple entities or locations. 29

The public review form starts with contact details and then asks about the company, industry and annual insurance spending. It requests a conversation about your program; it does not display an insurance price. 29

The portfolio page describes appointing WithCoverage on existing policies by signing a broker-of-record letter. This changes your broker, not the policy itself. The page says the transfer has no additional charge. 35

For its portfolio offering, WithCoverage describes a digital application transferred into insurers’ applications and an advisor-prepared comparison of options. 35

At the time of research, the page linked as Privacy Policy displayed the terms-of-service text rather than a separate detailed privacy notice. Before sharing policy or claims files, request the applicable privacy notice and document-retention terms. 40

Servicing and renewals

Pie’s policyholder account tutorial describes payment-method updates, instant or custom workers’ compensation certificates, policy details and downloads for policies, state posters, certificates and endorsements. Agent-served customers may need their agent for a custom certificate. 15,16

Pie requires an annual workers’ compensation premium audit that replaces estimated payroll with actual payroll information. Its audit partner may request payroll and employee records, cash-expense details and subcontractor certificates, so the final premium can differ from the initial estimate. 19

Pie says it sends a workers’ compensation renewal quote about 30 days before the current term ends for the policyholder’s review and acceptance. 16

WithCoverage describes a named risk manager backed by attorneys and claims specialists, handling renewals, certificates of insurance and account questions. Its platform brings policies, claims, certificates, exposures and renewal communications together. 32,26

The portfolio page says WithCoverage is not a law firm and does not provide legal services. Confirm what its attorneys’ involvement includes. 35

The portfolio page promises no fee to end its broker-of-record appointment and data return on request. Confirm the service agreement and separate policy cancellation charges. 35,28

Its advisor recruitment materials describe contract changes and larger deductibles as possible strategies. Ask which risks the proposal leaves with your business. 36

Fees and compensation

Published workers’ compensation options include annual, semi-annual, quarterly and monthly schedules, plus pay-as-you-go. The monthly schedule requires 16.6% upfront followed by ten monthly payments; pay-as-you-go uses reported payroll and no initial deposit. 17,18

Pie publishes a 3% credit-card convenience fee for new, single-state workers’ compensation policies, except in Florida, Nebraska, Maryland and Rhode Island. Its page does not describe this fee for multi-state or renewal policies. 17

Pie says each specific or blanket waiver-of-subrogation request carries a charge set by state rules and disclosed individually; the public FAQ does not give a dollar schedule. 16

Pie says partner agents receive commissions on new and renewal workers’ compensation policies, and its legal footer says compensation rates can vary among insurers. The reviewed current pages do not publish the standard rate or the amount attached to a buyer’s policy. 21,5

WithCoverage says it typically agrees a flat fee before work begins, so compensation does not rise with the premium. Its consumer FAQ also allows commission-based arrangements. The public pages do not give a standard fee amount. 30

The terms allow premiums, commissions, installment, service, cancellation and flat fees disclosed with the service. A flat advisory fee therefore should not be read as an all-inclusive insurance price. 28

The solution page advertises average savings of 20–40% for clients spending over $1 million annually on insurance and risk-management services. It does not provide the sample size, measurement period or calculation needed to establish a comparable result for your business. 33

Industry pages show the same 20–40% figure as annual policy savings without repeating the solution page’s spending threshold. The broader presentation does not establish savings for smaller accounts. 33,29,30

Claims assistance

Pie asks policyholders to report a workplace injury within 24 hours through its online form, 24/7 phone line or email. After intake, it says a claims professional follows up, determines whether the policy covers the claim and explains applicable benefits if accepted. 20

Pie’s agency FAQ says Pie manages workers’ compensation claims in 34 states and CorVel handles Alaska, Mississippi, Nevada, New Mexico and Oregon. That 39-state split is not reconciled with the separately advertised 40-state-plus-D.C. footprint. 21,11,22

WithCoverage says its claims team, including attorneys, manages the claims process and recommends changes to reduce future exposure. That assistance is separate from the issuing insurer’s policy obligations and does not establish claims-payment speed or outcomes. 33,28

Sources

Pie Insurance Official Website

  1. Pie Insurance. Pie Insurance; Homepage: small-business audience; direct workers’ compensation quote; online account; footer entity, insurer and availability qualifications. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  2. About Pie Insurance. Pie Insurance; About Pie; direct and agency distribution; footer legal disclosure. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  3. Workers’ Comp Insurance For Small Businesses. Pie Insurance; Quote inputs; coverage description; company-reported quote-time and savings qualifications; AM Best link. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  4. Terms Of Use. Pie Insurance; Updated 26 April 2022; Ownership and Agreement to Terms; geographic and product eligibility; policy controls coverage. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  5. Legal. Pie Insurance; State Licenses; footer disclosure naming producer and workers’ compensation versus third-party underwriting roles. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  6. Pie Insurance — Quote. Pie Insurance; Live unauthenticated first step: Business ZIP Code; inspected without entering data or advancing. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  7. Business Owner’s Policy. Pie Insurance; BOP definition; typical components; invitation to start a BOP quote; footer third-party insurer qualification. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  8. Cyber Insurance For Small Businesses. Pie Insurance; First- and third-party descriptions; carrier-partner quote invitation; policy-variation qualification. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  9. Errors And Omissions Insurance. Pie Insurance; E&O and professional-liability equivalence; typical claims; carrier-partner placement statement; footer third-party insurer qualification. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  10. General Liability Insurance. Pie Insurance; Typical covered categories; carrier-partner quote invitation; footer third-party insurer qualification. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  11. Workers’ Comp Coverage By State. Pie Insurance; Headline says 40 states and the District of Columbia; rendered state selector listed 39 state names and omitted New York and D.C.. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  12. Agency Document Library. Pie Insurance; Workers’ Comp State Documents: 40 named states plus Washington, D.C.. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  13. Pie Insurance Reports Strong 2025. Pie Insurance; 13 January 2026 release; Key 2025 Milestones says 39 states plus Washington, D.C.; company and distribution description. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  14. Commercial Auto Claim FAQs. Pie Insurance; Does Pie offer commercial auto insurance?; submission cutoff 1 December 2025; no new or renewal policies on or after 1 January 2026; legacy claim guidance. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  15. Online Account Tutorial. Pie Insurance; Payment-method updates; instant and custom certificates; policy information; document access; agent-handled custom certificate qualification. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  16. Workers’ Comp FAQs. Pie Insurance; Certificates; waiver request timing and state-dependent charge; billing and payments; renewal timing; annual audit; claims. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  17. Payment Options. Pie Insurance; Annual, semi-annual, quarterly, monthly and pay-as-you-go schedules; payment methods; 3% card fee and state exceptions. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  18. Pay-As-You-Go With Pie Insurance. Pie Insurance; No initial deposit; actual-payroll monthly premium; automatic deductions; payroll-provider coordination. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  19. Your Workers’ Comp Premium Audit. Pie Insurance; Required annual audit; estimated versus actual payroll; audit partner; requested payroll, employee, cash-expense and subcontractor certificate records. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  20. File Your Claim Within 24 Hours. Pie Insurance; Workers’ compensation reporting by online form, 24/7 phone or email; information requested; post-report coverage determination. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  21. Partner FAQ. Pie Insurance; Workers’ compensation claim handling in 34 states; CorVel handling in Alaska, Mississippi, Nevada, New Mexico and Oregon; producer commissions on earned premium. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  22. AM Best Rating Disclosure Report — Pie Casualty Insurance Company. AM Best Rating Services, Inc.; Page 1: A- (Excellent), Stable, affirmed 24 April 2026; page 14: rating unit, group insurer acquisitions, 100% workers’ compensation writing through PCIC and TPIC from 1 January 2024, 40 states and D.C.. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  23. The Pie Insurance Company — Company Details. Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance; Company name; active license status; NAIC 21857; property-and-casualty authority; 2025 workers’ compensation market data. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  24. Pie Casualty Insurance Company — Entity Details. Illinois Department of Insurance; Legal name; P&C Domestic Stock; active status; NAIC 10997; Pie Group Holdings, Inc. parent. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  25. Administrative Actions — January 2024. Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance; Allegations and Actions Against Companies: Pie Insurance Services, Inc. agreed to add a disclaimer to its “save up to 30%” advertising claim after misleading-advertising allegations. Accessed 2026-09-15.

WithCoverage Official Website

  1. Commercial Insurance & Risk Management. WithCoverage; Industry navigation; Your Risk Management Team; AI Analyzes; One Digital Platform tabs and policy-management showcase. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  2. About WithCoverage. WithCoverage; Opening description of risk management for businesses without an in-house team. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  3. Terms & Conditions. WithCoverage; Last revised June 28, 2024; §1 entities; §§7–8 availability and insurer obligations; §9 fees and charges. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  4. Technology Insurance & Risk Management. WithCoverage; Opening coverage description; policy-review request form; Have Questions? answers on the audit, broker change and assessment timing. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  5. Consumer Insurance & Risk Management. WithCoverage; Opening coverage description; Have Questions? answers on account management and flat-fee or commission compensation. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  6. Construction Insurance & Risk Management. WithCoverage; Opening coverage description; Have Questions? program-audit answer. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  7. Restaurant Insurance & Risk Management. WithCoverage; Opening coverage description; Have Questions? account-management answer. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  8. Risk Management & Commercial Insurance Solution. WithCoverage; Measurable Impact savings figure and spending-threshold footnote; Develop Risk Management Plan; Manage Claims & Safety Procedures. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  9. WithCoverage Raises $42M Series B. WithCoverage; Founders’ letter: WithCoverage fixes this in 3 key ways; complimentary risk assessment. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  10. Private Equity Portfolio Risk Management. WithCoverage; How We Earn Your Trust; One Master Application; Competitive Quoting Process; Policy Proposal and Comparison; footer notes [1]–[3] and [5]; no-legal-services disclosure. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  11. Commercial Risk Advisor Careers. WithCoverage; The work: contract changes and retained-risk strategies; Carrier network: direct appointments, wholesale relationships and displayed market names. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  12. With Coverage Insurance Services LLC — Agent Listing. Liberty Mutual; Named New York agency listing; About us description of insurer access. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  13. Insurance Licenses By State. WithCoverage; Licenses by state table, including Massachusetts 3002802342 and Maine AGN462479. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  14. With Coverage Insurance Services LLC — Foreign LLC Filing. Mississippi Secretary of State; Page 1, Business Information: entity name, Delaware organization date August 3, 2023, NAICS 524210; business ID 1410807, filed September 12, 2023. Accessed 2026-09-15.
  15. Privacy. WithCoverage; Page titled Privacy; June 28, 2024 terms revision date; §§1–12 terms text, including §§2 and 4 on privacy and data collection. Accessed 2026-09-15.

Updated . Spot, a product of Tools for Enlightenment, publishes this research and works in the commercial insurance market. Editorial policy. To suggest a correction, contact Spot with the page URL and supporting source.

Suggested Comparisons

All Comparisons

Let Spot Handle the Insurance Legwork.

Get help buying coverage and managing renewals, with less paperwork for your team. Start with a free consultation.

Talk to Spot