How Reliable Is WithCoverage?

WithCoverage reliability: licensing, legal entities, financial evidence and the scope behind its Spot Score.

Assessment

5.0/ 10

This partial Broker Spot Score covers carrier-network strength, disclosure clarity within the stated scope. It uses 45% of the rubric’s factor weighting, normalized to a ten-point scale. The excluded factors remain unknown, and evidence for one program does not describe another.

Partial score — 45% of this rubric’s factor weighting. Excluded: Identity and Authority, Regulatory Conduct

Assessed 2026-09-22 · Review due 2026-10-22

How the score is calculated

FactorWeightIncludedScoreBasis
Identity and Authority30%ExcludedCurrent authority and applicable appointments or delegations have not been independently established across the assessed scope.
Carrier-Network Strength30%66.7%normalized2.0 / 4[2][3][5][9][1]
Regulatory Conduct25%ExcludedA complete, exact-entity regulatory-conduct review for the preceding five years is unavailable.
Disclosure Clarity15%33.3%normalized2.0 / 4[2][1][5][7][3][9][4]

Included weights are normalized over the supported factors.

Evidence and Scope

Role: Broker. Scope: With Coverage's US commercial-insurance brokerage and risk-advisory activity at the named-entity level, including With Coverage Inc. and With Coverage Insurance Services LLC where official terms, regulator filings or carrier directories identify them. No insurer, MGA or policy-risk-bearing role is included.

With Coverage's terms distinguish With Coverage Inc. and With Coverage Insurance Services LLC. The license table and Liberty Mutual directory identify With Coverage Insurance Services LLC as an insurance-services/brokerage entity; no reviewed source identifies either entity as a policy insurer.[2][1][5]

Licensing

With Coverage publishes a current table for With Coverage Insurance Services LLC with entries across the states and DC, including California 6011578, Massachusetts 3002802342, Maine AGN462479, New York PC-1820286 and BR-1820286, and Wisconsin 3002709243. These are company-reported disclosures and do not establish active authority, appointments or product eligibility without state-specific confirmation.[1]

Wisconsin OCI explains that a firm's authority lies with its DRLP and active lines, so the published Wisconsin number alone does not establish authority for a particular account.[7]

Financial Strength

The reviewed With Coverage materials describe brokerage operations and disclose business or funding context, but do not publish entity-specific audited financial statements, statutory surplus, capital or liquidity figures, or an insurer financial-strength rating. Funding or investor information would not establish insurance solvency for a broker and is not used as a rating proxy.[3][2]

Risk Bearing

With Coverage describes placing and servicing commercial insurance and its terms distinguish broker services from insurer obligations. The actual policy issuer, capacity and reinsurance must be established from the quote and policy; no With Coverage-owned risk-bearing role was evidenced.[2][3]

One With Coverage carrier relationship is evidenced, and the carrier publishes it. Liberty Mutual’s independent-agent directory lists WITH COVERAGE INSURANCE SERVICES LLC at 25 E 21st St Fl 10, New York, NY 10010, with a named agent. That is carrier-published rather than company-reported and establishes that Liberty Mutual presents With Coverage as one of its independent agents. The listing states no lines, limits, states or commercial binding authority, and its descriptive text is Liberty Mutual’s standard independent-agent copy rather than a statement about With Coverage’s book.[5]

With Coverage itself names no insurer. Its terms state that any insurance coverage is subject to underwriting, carrier terms and exclusions, and that With Coverage makes no guarantee that quotes, terms, rates, coverage or services offered by insurers or other third parties will be available or suitable. Its client page refers to carriers only through customer testimonials — a competitive workers’ compensation, auto and general liability request for proposal, a reclassification agreed with its carrier partners, and six carriers placed alongside an incumbent builders-risk insurer — and names no insurer in any of them. Its published licence table records producer licence numbers in 49 jurisdictions, not carrier appointments.[2][9][1]

The Liberty Mutual listing is therefore the only carrier-published evidence of a With Coverage carrier relationship located in this research, and no panel, programme, capacity figure or binding authority is disclosed in any source Spot could open. That describes the available disclosures rather than the relationships With Coverage holds.[5][2]

Claims Service

With Coverage describes risk-advisory, policy-review and claims/safety-process support. That documents an intermediary service function, while the insurer and policy determine claims authority and payment obligations.[4][2]

Regulatory Record

The reviewed sources establish company-reported license disclosures and entity corroboration but do not complete a five-year regulatory or enforcement result for With Coverage Inc. or With Coverage Insurance Services LLC. No conclusion is drawn from that incomplete search.[1][8][7]

Evidence gaps

  • Independent current regulator confirmation of the published state licenses, DRLPs, appointments and active lines.
  • Exact contracting entity for a buyer account and reconciliation of With Coverage Inc. with With Coverage Insurance Services LLC for that account.
  • Entity-specific audited financial statements, capital/liquidity evidence and any insurer or MGA relationships.
  • Policy-specific insurer, claims administrator, capacity and reinsurance identification.
  • Complete five-year regulatory and enforcement search.
  • Liberty Mutual’s agent directory is the only carrier-published evidence of a With Coverage carrier relationship, and it states no lines, states, limits or commercial binding authority.
  • With Coverage’s own site, terms and client page name no insurer for any placement, and no panel, programme, capacity figure or binding authority is disclosed; the published licence table records producer licences rather than carrier appointments.

Jurisdiction searches

JurisdictionResultNotes
CaliforniaCalifornia Department of InsuranceSource inaccessible[8]Reviewed California business-name lookup route for With Coverage Insurance Services LLC; current authority was not independently established.
WisconsinWisconsin Office of the Commissioner of InsuranceNot researched[1][7]With Coverage publishes Wisconsin 3002709243; Wisconsin OCI Agent FAQ identifies the relevant authority rule, but current authority was not independently established.
United StatesNot researched[1]The company publishes a broad state table; complete current regulator reconciliation was not completed.

Licenses and Authority

These are reviewed authority records for the named legal entities and scope. A license record does not establish that a particular policy is available, bound, or suitable.

Entity and jurisdictionIdentifierLicense class and authority
With Coverage Insurance Services LLCCaliforniaState license: 6011578[1]Producer license as displayed by company; Company-disclosed producer authority; current regulator status not independently verified
With Coverage Insurance Services LLCMassachusettsState license: 3002802342[1]Producer license as displayed by company; Company-disclosed producer authority; current regulator status not independently verified
With Coverage Insurance Services LLCMaineState license: AGN462479[1]Agency license as displayed by company; Company-disclosed agency authority; current regulator status not independently verified
With Coverage Insurance Services LLCNew YorkState license: PC-1820286[1]Property and casualty broker license as displayed by company; Company-disclosed broker authority; current regulator status not independently verified
With Coverage Insurance Services LLCWisconsinState license: 3002709243[1]Producer license as displayed by company; Company-disclosed producer authority; current regulator status not independently verified
With Coverage Insurance Services LLCNew YorkState license: BR-1820286[1]Broker license as displayed by company; Company-disclosed broker authority; current regulator status not independently verified

Sources

  1. Licenses. With Coverage; Current state license table for With Coverage Insurance Services LLC, including California 6011578, Massachusetts 3002802342, New York PC-1820286 and BR-1820286, and Wisconsin 3002709243. Accessed 2026-09-22.
  2. Terms Of Use. With Coverage; Legal entity and service terms identifying With Coverage Inc. and With Coverage Insurance Services LLC; insurer obligations, broker services and fees sections. Accessed 2026-09-22.
  3. Company. With Coverage; Company and brokerage description, commercial insurance services and operating context. Accessed 2026-09-21.
  4. Risk Advisors. With Coverage; Risk-advisory, policy review, claims and safety-process support descriptions. Accessed 2026-09-21.
  5. With Coverage Insurance Services LLC — Local agents in New York, NY. Liberty Mutual; Agency listing for WITH COVERAGE INSURANCE SERVICES LLC at 25 E 21ST ST FL 10, New York, NY 10010, with a named agent and Liberty Mutual’s standard independent-agent description; carrier-published agency relationship, not proof of every license, line or appointment. Accessed 2026-09-22.
  6. Mississippi Secretary Of State Business Search. Mississippi Secretary of State; Business filing record for With Coverage Insurance Services LLC; entity-identity corroboration. Accessed 2026-09-21.
  7. OCI Licensing Frequently Asked Questions. Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance; Agent FAQ, Business Entities/Firms: firm authority depends on its Designated Responsible Licensed Producer and actively held lines; State Based Systems is the lookup path. Accessed 2026-09-21.
  8. Clients. With Coverage; Client testimonials referring to a competitive workers’ compensation, auto and general liability RFP, a reclassification agreed with carrier partners, and six carriers placed alongside an incumbent builders-risk insurer; no insurer named. Accessed 2026-09-22.

Updated 2026-09-22. Spot publishes this editorial research as an interested participant in the commercial-insurance market; it is not a guarantee of provider performance, policy coverage, or claims outcomes. See the editorial policy or contact Spot with a correction and supporting source.

Let Spot Handle the Insurance Legwork.

Get help buying coverage and managing renewals, with less paperwork for your team. Start with a free consultation.

Talk to Spot